This document calls on Catholic leaders to reject replacement theology and defines systematic anti-Zionism as a contemporary form of antisemitism incompatible with the Nostra Aetate: of 1965:
“…Unfortunately, in the centuries that followed, St. Paul’s confidence in the irrevocability of God’s covenant with Israel was forgotten. A contrary belief gradually took hold: that God had rejected the Jewish people and punished them by sending them into perpetual exile. Although widespread in Catholic theological commentary and preaching, this theological supersessionism never became official Catholic doctrine…”
Key arguments and commitments in the appeal include:
-
Theological Basis: Affirming that God’s promises to Israel were never revoked in the New Testament and citing Romans 11:29 to reject the notion that the Church has replaced Israel.
-
Balanced Stance: Supporting Israel’s right to exist and defend itself against existential threats while simultaneously upholding justice for all inhabitants and condemning violence by extremists on any side.
-
Call to Action: Urging bishops, theologians, and Catholic media to clearly speak against anti-Israel sentiment and to teach the Church’s authentic doctrine on Judaism as an integral part of Catholic formation.
-
Scope: The statement has garnered signatures from over 150 Catholic clergy, scholars, and laity, including notable figures like Gavin D’Costa and Brigitte Gabriel, while also inviting non-Catholics to support the initiative.
Support Our Work via JTOD.org/Give.
Sources: For Zion’s Sake: A Catholic Appeal in Support of Israel: https://www.catholicsforisrael.com/welcome/catholic-voices-for-israel/330-for-zions-sake-a-catholic-appeal-in-support-of-israel Declaration on the Relation of the Church to Non-Christian Religions Nostra Aetate 4 (1965): https://www.catholicsforisrael.com/resources/church-documents/135-nostra-aetate