Day 720: Gantz, Former Minister of Defense: What the World Gets Wrong About Israel

A strong articulation of Israel’s current viewpoint can be found in a recent opinion piece by Benny Gantz, a former Israeli minister of defense and member of the war cabinet since October 7, 2023.  He argues that Israel’s security actions following the Hamas attacks are driven by strategic necessity, not partisan politics, emphasizing that the nation’s core security interests reflect a broad national consensus rather than the agenda of any single leader, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Gantz stresses that the October 7 attacks constituted a strategic rupture, fundamentally altering Israel’s security calculus and necessitating a robust military response.

He rejects the growing international push for unilateral recognition of Palestinian statehood, asserting it would reward terrorism and undermine Israel’s security consensus. Gantz points to the 2005 withdrawal from Gaza and the subsequent Hamas takeover as a cautionary tale, arguing that the Palestinian Authority has failed to provide accountable governance, combat terrorism, or cease incitement against Israel. He insists that any future Palestinian autonomy must be contingent on verifiable de-radicalization and security cooperation.

Furthermore, Gantz outlines specific security requirements he views as non-negotiable, including a long-term Israeli military presence around Gaza to prevent Hamas’s rearmament and the formal assumption of control over the strategic Jordan Valley in the West Bank to prevent infiltration. He underscores that Israel’s security is not only vital for its own survival but also anchors regional stability, protects global interests like energy and shipping, and serves as a bulwark against Iran’s regional ambitions and the spread of radical ideologies.

Pray about Supporting Our Work in a Challenging Region and Time (JTOD.org/donate) 

“Since Oct. 7, 2023, from my position both in Israel’s war cabinet and in the opposition, I have watched how some in the West have misinterpreted Israel’s actions …”
Source:
NYTimes Opinion | What the World Gets Wrong About Israel – The New York Times

Opinion | What the World Gets Wrong About Israel – The New York Times There are deep political divisions and disagreements in Israel, but the nation’s core security interests are not partisan property. 
“Since Oct. 7, 2023, from my position both in Israel’s war cabinet and in the opposition, I have watched how some in the West have misinterpreted Israel’s actions …”
https://web.archive.org/web/20250924100252/https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/24/opinion/israel-war-security.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/24/opinion/israel-war-security.html

 

Protectors of Hamas want an apology for Israel’s attack

Qatar shelters and pays for Hamas, which in its 1988 Hamas Charter is dedicated to Israel’s complete destruction. Yet when Israel fights back in order to survive then Qatar feels entitled to an apology? Make this make sense:

Jerusalem Post, 21 Sept 2025 pg 1.

Hamas attacks Jews from Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, the West Bank (Samaria and Judea), and has leadership which dwells in Qatar with meetings also scheduled from time to time in Iran.

 

Below, a roadside banner featuring a photo of Israeli hostage in Gaza named Inbar Haimon, age 27:

 

Visible from the bus: “I’m also a Woman. Return me, too””

Pray to Help Us Keep Going: JTOD.org/donate/

 

Related post:

“Why won’t the Jews just let themselves be killed?”

Secret Iran Battle Plans from June ‘25 Released

We see below that Israel’s leaders and IDF did not consider Iranian oil refineries as a target unless Iranian civilians were to be moved out first.
Captured at Times of Israel, 16 Sept 2025.

It is not known how Channel 13 acquired a transcript of this secret top-level meeting.

 

Pray about Supporting Our Work in a Challenging Region and Time (JTOD.org/donate) 

 

 

Source:

https://www.timesofisrael.com/a-historic-moment-leaked-transcripts-reveal-secret-deliberations-at-start-of-iran-war/

Why won’t the Jews just let themselves be killed?

https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/10/16/why-wont-the-jews-just-let-themselves-be-killed/

 

“Everything Israel does is a war crime. Everything. Killing civilians – war crime. Trying not to kill civilians – war crime. Bombing populated areas – war crime. Giving a population time to leave before dropping bombs – war crime. The surrealism of these screams of ‘genocide!’ every time an Israeli soldier so much as picks up his gun…

“…Got that, Israel? ‘Punish’ Palestinians and you’re a criminal. Do everything in your power to avoid ‘punishing’ Palestinians and you’re still a criminal. I’m starting to wish the Israel-haters would just say what they mean with their entire chest: ‘Let yourselves be killed, Jews. Don’t fight back. Don’t do anything at all.’…” (Brendan O’Neill writing for Spiked on 2023-10-16)

Clipped article excerpt from Spiked Magazine:

Why won’t the Jews just let themselves be killed?

 

Pray to Help Us Keep Going: JTOD.org/donate/

 

Extra Links:
(1) "...tells the civilians of Gaza to leave first..."
https://www.aljazeera.com/gallery/2023/10/13/palestinians-flee-their-homes-towards-southern-gaza-after-israeli-order#:~:text=Thousands%20of%20Palestinians%20have%20begun%20to%20flee%20their%20homes%20in%20the%20Gaza%20Strip%20after%20the%20Israeli%20military%20called%20for%20all%20civilians%20in%20the%20northern%20half%20of%20the%20besieged%20enclave%20to%20relocate%20south%2C%20as%20it%20amassed%20tanks%20for%20an%20expected%20ground%20assault.

(2) "...claimed the first..." 
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/israel-leo-varadkar-gaza-mary-lou-mcdonald-taoiseach-b2428982.html

(3) "...the second..." 
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/israel-palestinian-gaza-strip-evacuate-b2429140.html


Main article (worthy read):
Why won’t the Jews just let themselves be killed?

Day 705: Comments on Charlie Kirk assassination

Excellent analysis by a former US military sniper.

He concludes this was a shot taken with training, however some of the assassin’s choices were unprofessional and risky.

Jerusalem Post & Wall St. Journal: The hunter’s rifle was found wrapped in a blanket in the woods. Casings engraved with transexual motifs:

https://www.jpost.com/international/article-867173

Fox personalities who knew Charlie well around 10 years offers comments and meaning:

Charlie Kirk destroys pro-palestinians in debate:

Pray and Help Us Keep Going at JTOD.org/donate/

Left wingers in a celebratory mood; why do they love violence so much:

Charlie Kirk debates abortion apologists:

Pray and Help Us Keep Going at JTOD.org/donate/

Thoughts from South Africa:

In this short 1min clip, Charlie confronts a Trump-hater with truth, which is enough to send that leftist running away from the microphone:

Charlie Kirk spoke about the Sabbath:

Pray and Help Us Keep Going at JTOD.org/donate/

Day 691: Israel apologized, yet is vindicated

Israel apologized for its choice of weapon used; however the hospital did attempt to shelter terrorists.  Legally, this converted the hospital from civilian use into military use, rendering the hospital a legitimate military target.

But first: On Fri night, Yemen fired a multi-missile type of missile around 9 PM, which is Shabbat in Israel at a moment when families are gathered around the table for the feast.  This morning, 27 Aug at 5:27 am, Yemen fired again.  On Shabbat was the first time Yemen has used such a high-technology type of missile that splits in midflight from one missile to a group of missiles, making them harder to intercept.   In my area, I had to run for the bomb shelter on
Shabbat, since the air raid sirens sounded locally.  It was feeding time for my two male cats, so I took their food with me and they followed me into the shelter.  So then a couple days later on Monday the 25th, Israel retaliated at a Houthi fuel storage facility, and a weapons factory in Yemen, and also at top military leaders among the Houthi military.  So – Yemen ramped up the level of missiles, so then Israel escalated the punishment, moving towards assassinations, as Israel has done against nuclear and military leaders in Iran:

 

Jerusalem Post, 2025-08-25 pg 1.

 

Later that day in Gaza, the IDF took action at a hospital in Gaza, having information and intelligence that the hospital was now a legal military target, since Hamas had converted the hospital for military use.  Legally, that makes the location legal to strike.  Civilians died, and there had been some confusion about Hamas’ military assets, and so Israel apologized:

Jerusalem Post, 2025-08-26 pg 1.

 

In the end, Israel proved that six of the dead are terrorists in reality. Thus, the apology from Israel is now the choice of weapon used in the strike, not the strike itself.  The strike itself is legal; however, Israel questions who made the choice for that type of weapon, and what was the justification for that choice:

Jerusalem Post, 2025-08-27 pg 1.

 

This is the kind of nuance that is necessary to get the proper picture.

 

Pray and Send Us Support to Continue Our Work In Israel. https://JTOD.org/donate/

 

David Defense:  Donate Supplies for Civilian Self-Defense as sheep among wolves (Psalm 144):   https://JTOD.org/defense/

 

Psalm 144: A Combo Meal of a Psalm

 

 

Day 682: Protestors blocked highways

The view of the highway from inside the bus: 

Protestors blocking the highway, viewed from inside a public bus. Hebrew signs read “Everyone” and “Until the Last Hostage.”
Approximate location was a little south of that blue point, back at the intersection at B’Koa.

 

Pray and Donate to Our Work

 

 

🎵 Shavua Tov! Day 682: Remembering the POWs. I now regularly lead worship in Jerusalem as part of a band in congregation there. So yesterday morning I headed out the door at 6am expecting to make it to Jerusalem by 8 am, and have time to take care of myself before the 10am rehearsal. Protestors blocked all the highways – they want the government to stop the war, get back the hostages–no matter that Hamas never negotiates–just, “Government, do miracles–that’s it!”

So – the Highway 1 was blocked, my bus tried to reroute around via the 6, the 431, and the 3; protesters blocked those too. As Herb Keinon published in the JPost this morning, hmmm, Hamas must be watching their televisions thinking, “man, those Israelis sure have lack of unity. Let’s hold on to those hostages some more and refuse to negotiate. We’re winning, obviously!’

On the one hand, it’s a conflict of interest to defeat Hamas while preserving all the lives of the POWs. One goal cancels out the other goal. This isn’t an Entebbe rescue, where the kidnappers just happened to land there in a civilian airport which is open to attack from elite commandos. Gaza is not civilian, it’s a military base – they built it as a military city underground with more tunnels than the Paris Subway. The civilians are just protection for the military equipment and structures.

Getting the POWs out safely is one insurmountable task. Defeating Hamas is an opposite goal. Aiming for both targets – well – impossible since they cancel each other out.  And on the other side, the protesters have two opposing goals: Either protest, seeking to defeat your own government, OR get the hostages back. You cannot get the POWs back by weakening the Israeli government.

Below, a psychiatrist explains what life as a POW is like, mentally:

After sitting for hours at the blocked intersections listening to annoyed drivers leaning on their horns, I did arrive at the meeting hall by 9:30 with my harp.

 

Left:  WLC: Westminster Leningrad Codex; / Right: HNV: Hebrew Names Version

 

Pray and Donate to Our Work

 

Trust the process, thru YHWH – Proverbs 16:3

Day 672: Send Them Now: Hostage families sail to Gaza with a message: “Let Them Go Now!”

 

Day 672: “Send Them Now:” Hostage families sail to Gaza

Finally! The hostage families, 22 months in, finally begin to get a sense of reality. Stop trying to pressure the Israeli government – its hands are tied in trying to get the hostages back from Gaza. The government is not a god; the government is not all-powerful. And, the government is forced by morality to command the army to execute a war with the goal of keeping us all safe.

The right address for pressure regarding the hostages is Gaza. That’s the address.  Gazans are the ones who must be pressured.  I’ve been saying for 22 months, the correct slogan is not “Bring Them Home Now,” it’s “Let Them Go Now.” The banner on this boat carrying hostage families to Gaza reads, “Send Them Now.” 

 

Jerusalem Post, 8 Aug 2025, pg 1.

In other news:

  • Trump strongly encourages the entire Middle East to join the Abraham Accords.
  • The IDF makes a statement near to its conclusion of Operation Gideon’s Chariots.

Pray to Aid and Support Our Work.

 

https://JTOD.org/donate/why-we-need-your-support/

 

Sources:

Hostage families sail to Gaza:
https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/article-863535

IDF statement:
https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/article-863541

Trump's message to the Middle East: 
https://www.jpost.com/international/article-863542

Fox News forgot about the DC attack on Jews

Fox did a story of increase in violent street crime in Washington DC and in New York City, showing this frame:

Fox News YouTube channel on 6 Aug 2025. (2)

However, in DC there was a high-profile murder case in May, 2025. Why would that incident not be included with these three above?

The two victims struck by gunfire and killed were identified as Yaron Lischinsky, 30, and Sarah Lynn Milgrim, 26, a young couple about to become engaged to be married. (3)
This May, a Jew-hater shot people down on a sidewalk in DC just because they are Jews. That’s possibly all he knew about them individually; and for him, that was enough. He traveled all the way from Chicago to the Capitol because he learned of a Jewish event taking place near the Israeli Embassy.

Today we learn that the murderer may be charged on federal charges, which would open the possibility of a death penalty (1):

“The US Department of Justice is expected to seek the death penalty for the man accused of killing Israeli Embassy staffers Yaron Lischinsky and Sarah Lynn Milgrim in Washington, DC, back in May, CNN reports.” (1)

The Department of Justice will pursue hate crime charges. (4)

Pray to Aid and Support Our Work.

 

https://JTOD.org/donate/why-we-need-your-support/

 

Sources:


(1) https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/us-justice-dept-said-seeking-death-penalty-for-dc-shooting-suspect-elias-rodriguez/


(2) https://youtu.be/JS0BK2zPe70


(3) https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/two-israeli-embassy-staffers-killed-washington-shooting-2025-05-22/

(4) https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/alleged-perpetrator-shooting-washington-dc-charged-hate-crimes