UN Watch Criticism of the Colonna Report
UN Watch, a Geneva-based NGO, has strongly criticized the Colonna Report, calling it a “whitewash” and “rigged” to exonerate UNRWA and restore donor funding rather than conduct an impartial investigation.
Key Criticisms
Conflict of Interest and Bias:
UN Watch argues that former French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna had a conflict of interest, as France is a major UNRWA donor. They claim her mandate was to “reassure donors” and “restore confidence”, not to investigate impartially.
Pre-Determined Outcome:
UN Watch cites statements from UN officials and Colonna herself indicating the review was designed to “provide cover” for donors to resume funding, suggesting a predetermined outcome.
Dismissal of Evidence:
The organization claims the review ignored extensive evidence it submitted, including hundreds of pages, screenshots, and videos showing UNRWA staff promoting terrorism.
Biased Research Institutions:
The three research institutes involved—Chr. Michelsen Institute, Raoul Wallenberg Institute, and Danish Institute for Human Rights—are accused of having pro-UNRWA and anti-Israel biases, with histories of dismissing allegations of terror ties.
Failure to Address Systemic Issues:
UN Watch highlights that the report downplayed the politicization of staff unions and failed to address the scale of Hamas infiltration, despite evidence that over 1,400 UNRWA employees in Gaza were members of Hamas or Palestinian Islamic Jihad.
Lack of Accountability:
As of late 2025, UNRWA had not implemented any recommendations related to staff union neutrality, further undermining the report’s impact.
Sources:
Exposed: UNRWA’s Rigged “Independent” Review
https://www.timesofisrael.com/unrwa-review-israel-hasnt-provided-evidence-that-agency-staff-were-terror-group-members/
Report: UNRWA Rigged ‘Independent’ Probe To Whitewash Its Pervasive Terror Ties
The Case of Fathi Sharif: Head of UNRWA Teachers Union is Hamas Terror Chief
NEW: Refuting UNRWA Facts Versus Claims
The Case Against UNRWA











